ASMR Matchup Rules!
This is for fun only. I love both of these ASMR artists!
Each category has 1 point available – most points wins!
Mad P ASMR vs KatieASMR
Mad P ASMR, or Madalina, is a super popular American ASMRtist who creates content on Role Play, Pat Downs, Collabs and Medical processes.
KatieASMR is a newer American ASMRtist who has a quirky approach to patdowns, medical, roleplay, therapy and collabs.
ASMR Style Variations
Here we look at how many and what variety of types of ASMR each person creates.
Madalina: Has quite a wide variety of ASMR styles including Role Play, Pat Downs, Medical, Dental, Make Up, Fast & Aggressive and Collaborations
Katie: Slightly fewer as she has been as active for as long as Madalina. She does cover Medical, Collab, Patdown, Roleplay andAlternative Medicine.
Score: 1 point to Madalina
Quality of Video
Rating the production quality of content created, visuals, sound and props
Madalina: Obviously been going longer so has a high quality of sound and setting as well as loads of props. Good use of camera angles.
Katie: Perhaps not quite as polished as Mad P yet but to be expected.
Score: 1 point to Madalina
Quirky Factor
Just how weird and unusual is the content?
Madalina: Solid performer, you know what you are getting which has its own merits.
Katie: Top level quirkiness from Katie. Love how odd some of her content is. Never sure exactly what is happening. Interesting thumbnails!
Score: 1 point to Katie
Collabs
So who has the best collabs?
Madalina: She really alerted me to the collabs that go on and of course she introduced Katie to her channel. She has some really neat 2 and 3 way collabs.
Katie: Of course Madalina has also appeared on KatieASMR’s channel along with their friend Ivy B ASMR. More collabs please!
Score: 1 point to Madalina
Stats attack!
Let’s look at some stats – subs, # of videos, views per video, frequency etc
Madalina: 175K subscribers, 456 videos, 46,018,724 views, joined 2021 -101k vpv
Katie: 45.9K subscribers, 90 videos, 7,607,432 views, joined 2022, 85k vpv
Score: 1 point to Madalina
Tingle Rating
Both score 4.5 out of 5 on our tingle rating. Super tingly!
So a point each! (I know, I broke the rules!)
Matchup Result!
Well the final score is 5 to Madalina and 2 to Katie – which seems a bit harsh!
Some of that scoring is due to Madalina having been active for longer.
Either way, both are great ASMRtists and I really do enjoy watching their content.
Make sure you check them both out!
| Criteria | Mad P ASMR | Katie ASMR |
| Style | 1 | |
| Quality | 1 | |
| Quirkiness | 1 | |
| Collab | 1 | |
| Stats | 1 | |
| Tingle | 1 | 1 |
| Results | 5 | 2 |
Who would you like to see feature next?
Let us know who you would like to see featured next via our contact form here or in the comments below.